The Aganorsa Rare Leaf Maduro Toro makes a strong first impression with its dark chocolate-colored Mexican San Andres wrapper. The cigar feels dense in hand with a tight and even pack throughout. Its surface shows a few prominent veins and a slightly toothy texture, balanced by a subtle sheen that catches the light. Seams are visible but tightly applied, and the cap is neatly finished, adding to its overall solid presentation.
The cigar opens with a bold surge of black pepper that quickly commands attention, backed by a bitter yet intriguing note of baker’s chocolate. A molasses sweetness works in harmony with the spice, creating an engaging foundation. Additional flavors emerge with salted nougat reminiscent of a Payday candy bar, supported by espresso and toffee. Retrohales carry a light pepper bite, offering a red pepper zing that lingers on the back of the palate. A hint of anise brings a subtle sweetness into the mix, while the smoke output is abundant and satisfying.
As the cigar transitions, the pepper begins to settle, allowing the core notes of coffee and cocoa to shine. A savory element of salted crackers appears, adding a layer of balance to the profile. By the halfway point, the strength steadies in the medium-plus range, and the flavors become more rounded. Coffee sweetness, light baking spices, and semi-sweet chocolate dominate this section, with richness and depth that feel both bold and controlled.
The final stretch is dominated by milk chocolate with a mellow sweetness that carries the cigar toward its finish. The once bold red pepper spice now softens into a subtle back-end note, letting cedar and almond flavors come forward. A touch of honey adds warmth and complexity. The cigar ends on a bold, assertive note that will appeal to smokers who enjoy strength, though it may be overwhelming for those unaccustomed to heavier cigars.
The Aganorsa Rare Leaf Maduro Toro offers a consistent and satisfying journey from start to finish, delivering a rich and chocolate-forward profile with moments of spice, sweetness, and nuttiness. The draw is just tight enough to provide resistance without frustration, though construction and burn performance have received mixed feedback from some smokers. Despite occasional issues with uneven combustion, the flavor profile is powerful, layered, and memorable. This cigar is a strong recommendation for experienced smokers who enjoy bold, full-bodied smokes with a chocolate and coffee backbone, while those sensitive to strength may find it a bit overwhelming.
Overall Score: 90.82 out of 100
Overall Strength Score: 6.77 out of 10
This Blind Review (Cigar #27-A) was conducted by the Cigar Review Team comprising of: Paul Nabs, Scott Treptow, Joe Hallett, Chris Safranski Brett Y., The Scuse, Chris Leblanc, Dan Johnson, Rob Smith, My Cigar Pilgrimage, BonerTom, Tripp and Rodney Mikell
