The Davidoff Winston Churchill Toro is a cigar that embodies the complexity and depth of the man it’s named after. Just as Winston Churchill navigated the various facets of life with charisma and determination, this cigar delivers a well-rounded experience, with an Ecuadorian wrapper, Mexican binder, & filler tobaccos from the Dominican Republic, and Nicaragua. The result is a sophisticated and layered smoke that evolves beautifully from start to finish.
Upon first glance, the cigar presents itself with an inviting baseball glove-brown wrapper that has a reddish hue. The wrapper is well-rolled, boasting excellent construction and a smooth texture with some visible veins. The cigar feels well-packed in hand, showcasing Davidoff’s trademark quality craftsmanship.
Lighting up the first third, a wave of spice greets the palate, with a dusting of white pepper that immediately makes its presence known. Oak wood, caramel, and milk chocolate emerge, adding a touch of sweetness. As the smoke develops, a musty, earthy cellar note (Davidoff’s calling card flavor) becomes prominent, accompanied by floral hints and a subtle green bell pepper essence. A light touch of citrus rounds out the initial flavors, setting the stage for an intriguing progression.
In the second third, the spice mellows slightly, but white pepper remains a defining characteristic. A surprising yet delightful note of buttered blueberry pancakes introduces a fruity sweetness, while leather flavors gain strength. Chocolate-covered peanuts add a rich, nutty dimension, and the floral notes continue to linger in the background, maintaining balance in the profile.
Entering the final third, the cigar holds onto its sweetness and bread-like qualities, while the white pepper once again steps into the spotlight. A burst of cedar wood brings a dry, woody complexity, and the musty notes make a return—leading one STARS Reviewer to accurately guess this was a Davidoff. Leather remains in the background, rounding out the experience with a refined finish.
Overall, the Davidoff Winston Churchill Toro is an expertly crafted cigar that delivers a smooth yet complex experience. It has a perfect draw and burn, producing ample smoke throughout. The flavor transitions are well-executed, ensuring consistency without losing the element of surprise. Despite its lighter appearance, the cigar carries more strength than expected, making it a solid choice for seasoned cigar veterans.
Overall Score: 90.50 out of 100
Overall Strength Score: 6.00 out of 10
This blind review (Cigar #20-D) was conducted by the Cigar Review Team comprising of: Rick Galletta, Tyler Ceola, JB Smith, Rob Brown, SamF, Travis Rodd, James Elliott, Bret Curry, Mike Conklin, George Hillman, J. Dwayne Corn, Nicholas Peters, & Eusebio G.
Price: $25.19 per single, $100.00 per 4 Pack, $500 per box of 20
