The EP Carrillo Encore Black, released in 2024, is a bold evolution of the original Encore line. Produced at Casa Carrillo in the Dominican Republic, this limited-production cigar showcases a richer profile, thanks to a Connecticut Broadleaf Maduro wrapper, a Mexican San Andrés binder, and a hearty filler blend from Condega, Estelí, and Jalapa in Nicaragua.
Visually, the Encore Black is striking. The dark chocolate-hued wrapper has a soft box-pressed form that feels substantial in hand. Its appearance alone hints at the depth of flavor to come — dense, oily, and smooth, with meticulous construction.
From the first draw, there’s a punch of spiced rum and pepper that grabs your attention. That initial heat quickly gives way to a more complex dance of cedar, espresso, and nutmeg, layered with earthy notes, anise, and a surprising graham cracker pie crust nuance. The pepper lingers just enough to remind you of its presence without overpowering.
In the second third, the pepper calms down, making room for a creamy wave of dark chocolate and almonds. A touch of cinnamon adds warmth, and the milkiness of the body rounds out the espresso and nutmeg duo. Cedar stays consistent, anchoring the evolving profile.
The final third delivers a crescendo of flavor: dark chocolate-covered espresso beans, baking spice, and a sweet-savory medley of honey and BBQ campfire notes. A slight metallic mineral note emerges near the end, adding an unexpected dimension to the lingering cedar finish.
This is a full-bodied cigar that doesn’t rely on brute strength. It’s nuanced, complex, and deeply relaxing, with an effortless draw, perfect construction, and never-ending smoke output. A standout for anyone who gravitates toward dark chocolate profiles or who’s seeking a unique experience beyond the typical cigar lineup.
Overall Score: 90.20 out of 100
Overall Strength Score: 6.60 out of 10
This Blind Review (Cigar #23-A) was conducted by the Cigar Review Team comprising of: Paul Nabs, Joe Hallett, Chris Safranski, Scott Treptow, Brett Y., Chris Leblanc, The Scuse, Boner-Tom Coleman, Dan Johnson, Josh Wright, , My Cigar Pilgrimage, & The Queen of The Corn
