The Gold Star Toro made a striking return with a refreshed look while maintaining the craftsmanship and legacy that cigar lovers have appreciated since 1995. Handcrafted at the Tabacalera William Ventura Cigar Factory in the Dominican Republic, this blend offers a balanced yet flavor-packed smoking experience with a medium-bodied profile. A careful mix of Dominican Ligeros, Criollo ’98, Corojo ‘98, and a touch of Connecticut Broadleaf ensures depth, while the Sumatra binder and Ecuador Habano 2000 Intermedio wrapper from the Quevedo region add complexity and finesse.
The Gold Star Toro presents an inviting light brown, milk chocolate-colored wrapper that leans toward a Colorado hue. Its smooth surface has a semi-gloss sheen with minimal veins, reflecting the expert craftsmanship behind its construction.
From the first draw, this cigar showcases layers of complexity. Cedar wood and a rich nuttiness take the forefront, followed by a caramel sweetness that lingers on the palate. The buttery texture and white pepper spice resemble an Italian cookie, while sourdough bread notes introduce a subtle tang. Hints of citrus, floral undertones, and leather round out the opening act, making for a dynamic yet balanced start.
The cedar backbone remains but allows other flavors to shine. A buttercream sweetness steps up, complemented by espresso and leather undertones. Nutty notes evolve, with cashews and peanut butter adding a creamy, savory contrast. Cinnamon emerges, enhancing the pepper spice and bringing a warm, lingering finish to each draw.
As the cigar progresses, the cedar wood begins to fade, making way for an intensified caramel sweetness and a more pronounced pepper kick. Unexpected yet intriguing, wasabi spice and soy sauce nuances appear, adding a layer of umami depth. The ever-present leather note continues to linger, while a delightful chocolate-covered cherry essence ties everything together, creating a memorable finish.
Gold Star Toro is an excellent everyday cigar, offering a deeply layered yet approachable flavor profile. The construction is flawless, boasting a perfect draw and an impressively sharp burn reminiscent of an X-Acto knife. Whether you’re a seasoned aficionado or a casual smoker looking for complexity without overwhelming strength, this box-worthy cigar delivers satisfaction with every puff.
Overall Score: 91.32 out of 100
Overall Strength Score: 5.45 out of 10
This Blind Review (Cigar #21-A) was conducted by the Cigar Review Team comprising of: Paul Nabs, Scott Treptow, Drew Seruya, Joe Hallett, Brett Y., Chris Leboner, The Scuse, Rob Smith, Boner-Tom Coleman, Dan Johnson, Josh Wright, Lesley of The Corn, & My Cigar Pilgrimage
