The Ozgener Karatoba Robusto is a box-pressed cigar crafted at the NACSA factory in Nicaragua. Cloaked in a dark Sumatra wrapper with an oily sheen and fine tooth, it boasts a rich, inviting appearance with visible veins hinting at the depth within. Its name, “Karatoba,” combines “Kara” (dark in Turkish) and “Toba” (a nod to Indonesia’s volcanic Lake Toba), a fitting title for a cigar that delivers a bold, complex experience from start to finish.
From the first light, this cigar sets the tone with a medley of leather, salt, and black pepper, underscored by coffee and subtle woodiness. As the burn progresses, sweeter elements emerge—cinnamon, vanilla ice cream, graham cracker, and marshmallow—bringing a surprising, dessert-like twist that balances beautifully against the savory spice.
In the second third, the pepper sharpens into freshly cracked form, met by notes of black tea and dark baker’s chocolate. Earthy mineral tones ground the profile, while a whisper of hot honey adds just the right amount of intrigue. The graham cracker note lingers in the background, harmonizing with the cigar’s inherent sweetness.
The final third continues the complexity. Salt and mineral tones rise to the surface, joined by a resurgence of dark chocolate and black pepper. Coffee and cinnamon make a welcomed return, complemented by a toasty bread character that rounds out the smoking experience.
The draw is exceptional, with excellent construction throughout and a captivating aroma that enhances the overall enjoyment. Medium in strength, the Karatoba is accessible to a wide range of palates and would pair wonderfully with an Old Fashioned. From light to nub, this cigar delivers a rewarding and flavorful journey that earns its place in any rotation.
Overall Score: 91.60 out of 100
Overall Strength Score: 4.88 out of 10
This blind cigar review (Cigar #21-B) was scored by a panel of cigar enthusiasts, including: Rev Eldon, Bill F, Jeff Endrizzi, Daniel, Ruby Cannoli, Chief16., Ryan Senica, Ryan M., Vincent Cammarata, Chris V, MI_Cigar_and_Drink, & Joey Bagodonuts
