Released in 2024, the Rocky Patel Gold Toro arrives with an Ecuadorian Habano wrapper that exudes a deep, dark maduro color, offering an oily sheen reminiscent of a fine chocolate bar. The box-pressed construction is impressive, tightly rolled with prominent veins that add to its rustic appeal. Beneath the wrapper, a double binder of Connecticut Shade and Connecticut Broadleaf secures a core of aged Nicaraguan fillers from Jalapa and Estelí, promising a layered and flavorful experience.
Upon lighting, the first third unveils an intriguing mix of Fig Newton and Nutella sweetness, balanced by nutty undertones, leather, and a spice that lingers. The aroma is rich and inviting, with hints of clove, salt, and a subtle jalapeño pepper that gives the profile an extra kick. The burn and draw are excellent, allowing for a steady and flavorful smoking experience.
Moving into the second third, the cigar deepens in complexity. The nuttiness intensifies, resembling peanut butter, while dark chocolate bitterness intertwines with caramel and burnt marshmallow. Wheat crackers add a toasty element, and the pepper remains present in the background, steadily building in strength. The retrohale amplifies the experience, making for an enjoyable balance of sweetness and spice.
As the cigar reaches the final third, the profile takes on a more robust character. Cedar, espresso, and leather continue to dominate, while molasses and a musty aged tobacco note emerge. The pepper ramps up, blending with a unique, meaty essence akin to peppered beef jerky. The transition is seamless, maintaining the richness and depth found throughout the smoke.
Overall, the Rocky Patel Gold Toro delivers a satisfying and well-rounded experience, with consistent flavors and excellent construction. The burn remains steady, the draw is effortless, and the cigar’s evolving complexity keeps it engaging from start to finish. One STAR noted that this blend unmistakably carries the Rocky Patel signature & was correct! Another STAR had a colorful remark about the flavor that I can’t repeat here but let’s just say Uncle Junior from “The Sopranos” would disapprove.
Overall Score: 89.70 out of 100
Overall Strength Score: 6.20 out of 10
This blind review (Cigar #19-D) was conducted by the Cigar Review Team comprising of: Rick Galletta, Tyler Ceola, JB Smith, Rob Brown, SamF, Travis Rodd, James Elliott, Bret Curry, Hassib Abou-Zaki – The Cigar Prophet, Mike Conklin, George Hillman, J Dwayne Corn, and Nicholas Peters
Price: $13.19 per single, $233.99 per box of 20
