RoMa Craft Maestranza Valencia Cigar Review

The RoMa Craft Maestranza Valencia, released in 2024, showcases the brand’s attention to detail and reputation for complex blends. It wears a Mexican San Andrés wrapper that is lighter in color yet reminiscent of the Neanderthal line. Beneath lies a Brazilian binder supporting fillers from the Dominican Republic, Honduras, and Nicaragua, making for a rich and layered profile right from the start.

In appearance, the Valencia presents itself with a dark brown wrapper and a soft rectangular box press. The wrapper is dry to the touch with a fine tooth and very few veins, showing off a clean roll. It feels well-packed in the hand, a sign of quality construction before the first cut.

The first third hits with an immediate blast of bold flavors. Leather and earth dominate early on, joined by cocoa and hazelnut. Black coffee and woody undertones develop quickly, followed by cinnamon, ginger, pecans, nutmeg, and semi-sweet chocolate chips. Hints of mushrooms and leather add a rustic depth, making this opening third both complex and attention-grabbing.

As the second third develops, the cigar mellows noticeably, settling into a smoother rhythm. Chocolate cake notes emerge with a subtle layer of raspberry, joined by smoky cedar and soft white pepper. Cinnamon sugar and coffee mingle with flavors of toast and pie crust. Earthiness lingers, balanced by unsweetened dark chocolate and hints of spice, keeping the profile dynamic while smoothing out from the initial intensity.

The final third brings a dessert-like sweetness layered with depth. Chocolate chip cookie dough, mocha, and creamy coffee lead the way. Nutmeg, dark chocolate, peanut butter, and ginger snap cookies weave together for a rich, warming profile. Leather and earth return on the finish, alongside burnt sourdough toast and black coffee. The last few draws introduce a musty note, closing the experience with an intriguing twist.

Overall, the Maestranza Valencia delivers an even burn, excellent draw, and constant evolution in flavor. While it hinted at being more full-bodied, it largely stayed at a balanced medium, making it approachable for smokers who want to explore stronger profiles without being overwhelmed. From its peppery leather blast at the start to its decadent dessert-like finish, this cigar commands attention and rewards a slow, thoughtful smoke. Well-constructed and flavorful throughout, it’s a refined offering from RoMa Craft that proves to be both eventful and satisfying.

Overall Score: 90.57 out of 100
Overall Strength Score: 5.57 out of 10

This blind cigar review (Cigar #26-B) was scored by a panel of cigar enthusiasts, including: Rev Eldon, Bill F, Jeff Endrizzi, Jeffery Knipe, Ryan M.,Chris V, & Joey Bagodonuts