The West Tampa Circle of Life Toro is more than just a cigar—it’s a moment of mentorship come full circle. A collaboration between Rick Rodriguez and his mentor, Ernesto Perez-Carrillo, this cigar was born at the famed Casa Carrillo factory in the Dominican Republic. While the exact blend remains a mystery, the experience it delivers is both meaningful and memorable, much like the name suggests. Is it a metaphor for the journey of a cigar lover, or a sly wink to “The Lion King”? Either way, it’s got depth.
Upon first glance, the Circle of Life Toro commands attention. The wrapper is dark and rugged, with a toothy texture that resembles bark on a weathered tree. Prominent veins run throughout, and it feels dense and solid in hand—well-packed and ready for the long haul.
Lighting up, the first third brings a swirl of leather and white pepper, balanced by a grainy, nutty undertone. Toast and dark chocolate add a rich layer, while a faint root beer sweetness and a touch of salt keep things lively and interesting.
Moving into the second third, the pepper steps up its game. Earthiness begins to take root, while that subtle saltiness holds its ground. Unexpected notes of cilantro, pumpernickel bread, and graham cracker join the mix, creating a rustic, bready complexity. Espresso comes through with a dash of caramel to round out this section—comforting and bold.
In the final third, the profile locks into a rhythm. Earth and pepper remain dominant, with the return of leather adding depth. Dark roast coffee, a consistent salty edge, hints of cedar, rye, and dark chocolate finish out the journey, maintaining the cigar’s robust and grounded personality.
Construction throughout was excellent—no touch-ups needed, and the draw stayed consistent from foot to nub. While the appearance suggests a powerhouse, the strength comes in just under medium-full. It’s a steady smoke with bold, earthy flavors and spice, but not the kind that overwhelms. Transitions are minimal, but the flavor is consistent and deeply satisfying.West Tampa Circle of Life Toro is a solid, well-crafted cigar that tells a story—not through flashy transitions, but through consistent, earthy flavor and impeccable craftsmanship. A fitting tribute to the bond between teacher and student, and a great companion for any smoker who appreciates cigars that speak with subtle strength.
Overall Score: 90.30 out of 100
Overall Strength Score: 5.88 out of 10
This blind cigar review (Cigar #21-C) was scored by a panel of cigar enthusiasts, including: Nick – The Cigar Pulpit, LKOUTS, Mike Cokeley, Munch, Justin Fultz, Jim DeLuca, AustinDan, Ray Forslund, Dwight Jones, Nick B, Hawkeye, Byron Robinson, Vito T, Kaleb Rosa, and PoDunkMofo
